Posts Tagged 'Maguire Properties'

Security Guard vs. Photographer

This is an old video from 2009 that was taken down by YouTube because the guard complained that his privacy was violated.   But it’s finally back on line, two years later, where it belongs since we all know that an expectation of privacy does not exist on a public sidewalk.

If any photographers are still being harassed by downtown Los Angeles security guards please document the encounter with video and let us know.

From YouTube:

A downtown Los Angeles security guard tells a photographer that he can’t photograph The Gas Company Tower from a public sidewalk without the property owner’s permission. The photographer informs the guard that that is not true.

Advertisements

Gas Tower Video Has New Home

1659259207_2f995674cf
The Biltmore Hotel, as reflected in The Gas Company Tower. Photo by teamperks

Enjoy the video here.

YouTube – More Like Censor You Tube

securedownload

Today YouTube caved to a “privacy violation” complaint and took down the video of our conversation with a The Gas Company Tower security manager. What’s most puzzling is the video doesn’t fall into any of the categories in their Community Guidelines. Not even from the Privacy section:

If a video you’ve recorded features people who are readily identifiable and who haven’t consented to being filmed, there’s a chance they’ll file a privacy complaint seeking its removal.

The great majority of the video is of the guy’s torso. But forget that for a minute: We were on a public sidewalk where there is no expectation of privacy.

What’s more, we regarded the encounter as informative and instructive, especially for the guard. Perhaps he’d go back to his supervisors and they’d brush up on the law so building security and photographers can finally all just get along. From our perspective, it was cordial and no one in their right mind (other than paranoid YouTube execs) would agree this discussion on photographers’ rights was a violation of someone’s privacy.  But it seems someone felt the need to file a bogus complaint.

This is setting a scary precedent. So from now on, anyone can complain to YouTube about a video they don’t like of themselves – like all those cops who beat protestors or smash into bicyclists? They’ll just sign up for an account, file a complaint, and – bam – no more public record?

Oh well, it’s not as if that will really make the video go away or anything. We’ll post a new link soon.

Photographers Effect Change at US Bank Tower

NPRO Creates Change at US Bank Tower

In January a small group of photographers went to shoot photos in downtown Los Angeles and at the US Bank Tower, a building notorious for its aggressive, overzealous security staff. At the time, we were threatened and bullied by six security personnel – and told by Patrick Silver, the supervisor on duty, that we were on a private sidewalk (we weren’t) and he was going to call the police (he was bluffing). It was an unpleasant encounter, not to mention a certain violation of our rights. (See the video here.)

This time though, someone higher up in the food chain had clearly reviewed their policy. During the NPRO Photographers’ Rights Rally today, we stopped at the Bank Tower, and after about 10 minutes of freely shooting, a friendly guard came out to tell us we were allowed to continue but he had to give us the above notecard. 

So, it seems, the questions, posts, calls and letters may have indeed been effective in changing the way UPS patrols its buildings. Interesting how that works.

Stay tuned for more videos and updates throughout the week of this year’s NPRO weekend  rally.

“Maguire Properties” Closes YouTube Account

 "Maguire Properties" Closes Youtube Account

In a move that many saw coming, the faux “Maguire Properties” closed their YouTube account after leaving threatening messages in the comments section of this video.

We’re not sure who closed the account or why, but we knew this would happen well before it actually did. So in order to have a record of what was said, screen grabs were taken of the “Maguire Properties” profile and of the threatening comments that they left. All of which, on top of some backlash they received, can be viewed in full here.

Contact Maguire Properties to voice your concerns:

Maguire Properties
355 South Grand Ave., Suite 3300 
Los Angeles, CA 90071 
Phone: (213) 626-3300 
Fax: (213) 687-4758

property.management@maguireproperties.com

And since City Council members Jan Perry and Eric Garcetti have not responded to two separate emails sent to their offices, please contact them as well and let them know how you feel about this ongoing issue.

Jan Perry, Council District 9
200 N. Spring Street, Room 420 
Los Angeles, CA 90012 
Phone: (213) 473-7009 
Fax: (213) 473-5946
Email: Jan.Perry@lacity.org
Website: http://www.lacity.org/council/cd9/

Eric Garcetti, Council President
200 North Spring Street, Room 470
Los Angeles, California 90012
Phone: (213) 473-7013
Fax: (213) 613 0819
Email: councilmember.garcetti@lacity.org
Website: http://www.lacity.org/council/cd13/

“Maguire Properties” Threatens Me on YouTube

maguirethreats

In an interesting development, someone purporting to be Maguire Properties has left two threatening comments on the US Bank Tower video on YouTube. The first said: “Please remove these photos of our employees, they were on duty and given instructions. Kindly remove this video or action will be taken.” 

While there is no fathomable way one can take “action” for a posted YouTube video of this sort, it might have been considered legit had a second poster not left this semi-literate comment: “Take my damn face off this page or when I see your on the streets, will be flying, shit  happens and things will be a blurr.”

Now it’s obvious that the person who created this “Maguire Properties” YouTube account is not the real Maguire Properties. But we also can’t say if the person who opened this account and left these threatening comments is one of  the guards, someone  affiliated with Maguire Properties, or  just somebody trying to escalate the situation.

Either way, this matter needed to be addressed for a number of reasons. So after contacting City Council members Jan Perry and Eric Garcetti and executives at Maguire Properties, US Bank and Universal Protective Services regarding these threats, I got a phone call from Peggy Moretti, Senior Vice President, Investor and Public Relations. I won’t go into what was said because it will end up being a “she said, he said” thing, however I do recall Ms. Moretti stating that Maguire Properties policies aren’t illegal.

I’m not sure if she has watched the video or listened to the longer audio portion, but I don’t understand how it’s not illegal for US Bank Tower guards to leave private property to confront photographers that are on public property, call them idiots and threaten them with arrest for doing something that is completely legal.

I’m not a lawyer, so I don’t know.

But I do know if we were really on private property like the guards stated, that means we were trespassing, however, we were never cited for trespassing or threatened with arrest for trespassing – only for taking photos of the US Bank Tower from public property.

Contact Maguire Properties to voice your concerns:

Maguire Properties
355 South Grand Ave., Suite 3300 
Los Angeles, CA 90071 
Phone: (213) 626-3300 
Fax: (213) 687-4758

property.management@maguireproperties.com

And since City Council members Jan Perry and Eric Garcetti have not responded to two separate emails sent to their offices, please contact them as well and let them know how you feel about this ongoing issue.

Jan Perry, Council District 9
200 N. Spring Street, Room 420 
Los Angeles, CA 90012 
Phone: (213) 473-7009 
Fax: (213) 473-5946
Email: Jan.Perry@lacity.org
Website: http://www.lacity.org/council/cd9/

Eric Garcetti, Council President
200 North Spring Street, Room 470
Los Angeles, California 90012
Phone: (213) 473-7013
Fax: (213) 613 0819
Email: councilmember.garcetti@lacity.org
Website: http://www.lacity.org/council/cd13/

US Bank Tower: The Aftermath

security
Photo by NoHoDamon

Our story is gaining steam, picked up by LAist, LA Observed, BlogDowntown, LA MetBlogs and Franklin Avenue, among others.

There has been a hearty back and forth about this issue, and that’s good. It’s getting attention for photographers’ rights, and bottom line, that’s what we’re after.

The reaction has been overwhelmingly positive, with photographers and regular folks alike chiming in about their similar experiences and outrage. But, of course, there are always those who will disagree with the mission and the method.

So, to address a few of the common complaints:

1. We didn’t pick the US Bank Tower out of the clear blue. It, along with a few other skyscrapers in downtown LA, have a history of aggressive, unwarranted harassment of photographers.

2. To those who say we didn’t accomplish anything: Universal Protective Services is actually taking this incident seriously, and one of the photographers involved is having a dialogue with executives there about their policy. There’s a good chance they’ll educate their staff better, and that’s a positive result.

002_35Photo by discarted

3. There is no federal, state or city law, code or provision that dictates that one can only photograph here or there or wherever. Some buildings have plaques or markers to signify where their private property begins. Beyond those markers, sidewalks and streets are public property. Photography is perfectly legal on public property. You do not have to ask for permission to practice your craft or your hobby, and you do not need a permit to shoot handheld in public. If your building or refinery or port is visible from a public sidewalk, deal with it. Download Bert Krages’ handy info sheet here.

4. The Patriot Act, enacted by a bully administration after a time of great tragedy (and the perfect example of Naomi Klein’s shock doctrine theory), is used to justify abuses of power and the stripping of many of our basic rights. But neither the Patriot Act or the Homeland Security Act say anything about restricting photography. It is possible terrorists are casing American sights to do harm to them, but one or two – or even six – schlubs with a camera do not really pose a threat to your building. There needs to be some case-by-case logic and thought involved in security guard and police enforcement of these blanket policies.

5. Perhaps some uncivil things were said. In the heat of the moment that happens. Overall this was a relatively pleasant encounter. (There’s been worse and…er, worser.) We realize these guys are just doing their job, but in your own profession, don’t you like to be armed with knowledge about what you’re doing and what your employers are telling you to do? These guards need to be trained better so they can react appropriately in situations like this.

017_201 Photo by discarted

6. Security Guards have no legal authority to enforce any laws whatsoever. They are citizens just like us, that’s it. They can not detain you, arrest you, harass you, threaten you, demand to see your ID, or do anything to you for that matter. They seek out the job, fill out an application and then are hired. Their job is to observe and report.

7. Did we go to the US Bank Tower looking for trouble?

No, we went there to shoot photos of the skyscrapers. Did we go prepared in case we were harassed and threatened by US Bank Tower security guards? Yes.

We knew it was very likely that we would be harassed and threatened, and we were right, because within a minute of arriving, the US Bank Tower guards were in our face. Unfortunately, our videographer showed up a little late and didn’t get the entire confrontation on tape. (Or the previous encounter that took place one a block away at another property managed by Maguire Properties.)

018_193Photo by discarted

8. Why didn’t we call the cops if we knew what we were doing was legal?

Well, we did – twice! Both times we called Officer Johnson at Central Station in downtown Los Angeles, and during both calls we were told that what we were doing was completely legal. We also asked the US Bank Tower guards during both encounters if they would speak with Officer Johnson, however, the security guards REFUSED TO SPEAK WITH A REAL COP – both times!

On top of that, David Sommars can be seen in the above photo, as well as in the video, talking to Officer Johnson. When he tells the US Bank Tower guard this, the guard responds by saying, “I don’t care because you don’t matter to me.”

US Bank Tower Guards Harass Photographers Photo by discarted

9. Why did we continue talking with the US Bank Tower guards and not ask to speak to their supervisors?

We did. When we asked Carlos, the nicer security guard out of the bunch, to speak with his supervisor, guess what? We were told that the most belligerent guard out of all of them was the swing shift supervisor.

So, to recap: The supervisor (above, with open jacket) was the guard that reached for one of our cameras, called us idiots, didn’t cared if he was fired because he had two degrees and refused to speak with law enforcement about the legality of what we were doing.

When we asked to talk to the executives above this guard, we were told they were not in – it was Sunday. (They were probably on their way back to Washington to ask for some more bailout money so they can continue paying these guys.)

024_13 Photo by discarted

10. To reiterate: We were on public property and we weren’t doing anything wrong. Know how we know? Because we weren’t charged or arrested for trespassing, nor were we ever told that we would be arrested for trespassing – just for taking photos … FROM A PUBLIC SIDEWALK!


Advertisements

%d bloggers like this: