No Shooting Shootings, Says Chicago Police

Photo by Mike Anzaldi

This kind of thing is expected in someplace like Nepal or China, but … Chicago?

Freelance photojournalist Mike Anzaldi was arrested on Tuesday by the Chicago Police Department while covering a shooting in the Englewood section of the city. He was charged with resisting and obstructing a peace officer, held for nine hours and had about 500 images deleted from his memory card.

No doubt tensions were high since an off-duty detective was involved in the shooting, but Freedom of the Press should apply at all news events, regardless. And as long as journalists abide by the law, law enforcement should too.

We asked Anzaldi for his side of the story. He frequently covers breaking news in Chicago, and when he heard about an officer-involved fatal shooting on the radio, he arrived at the scene and was shooting images and video on the property of a neighbor with about 20-25 other bystanders. The problem, he says, arrived in the form of Chicago Police Department spokeswoman Monique Bond.

As Anzaldi tells it:

She said I needed to stop shooting because this was a crime scene, and that there was an investigation going on.  She went on to confirm that I was OK to remain in my location, but that recording was the issue.  I complied.  …  A few minutes later, either a family member or friend of the victim arrived on scene.  Obviously, this person was emotional.  I turned the camera and chose to record that emotion.  Bond wasted no time in rushing right back to confront me about recording.  This time she demanded my CPD issued credentials.  This day, I did not have my credential necklace around my neck, but rather sitting on the front seat of my car- along with my wallet and cell phone.

Anzaldi says that the CPD credential doesn’t actually grant journalists access to incident scenes but only serves as an ID. In fact, he says the Chicago Tribune doesn’t even apply for them, such is their value. He concedes that the City of Chicago Municipal Code requires this ID to “pass police and fire lines for the purpose of gathering and editing spot news or photographing news events.” But, he maintains that he has “never been allowed across police lines, nor seen it done by any photographer, ever.”

He continues:

My position was outside of the police tape, period.  When Bond demanded the credential, I again insisted that it wasn’t on me, and that I didn’t need it anyway.  She argued and insisted that it was absolutely required to shoot news.  It was ultimately this lack of credential that fueled her argument.  She was flanked by uniformed cops and CPD Sergeant Keith Calloway who said, “I’ve seen enough, take him in.” 

Spokeswoman Bond’s statement to the media was that Anzaldi had crossed police lines and refused to leave when told to, which resulted in his arrest.

It took 6 guys, 5 phone calls and nearly 3 hours to come up with a charge.  They settled on obstruction.  My video camera and tape were confiscated, and kept.  My still cameras were held until my release, 9 hours later.  They were returned to me with the memory cards deleted.  As I signed myself out, I asked if we could make a report, or take note of the fact that the cards were deleted.  The District 7 commander and desk sergeant both said they would not make that note, and that deleting camera cards was not a crime anyway.  I was ordered to have a nice evening.

What really is hard to grasp here is how a person taking images and video – from across the street, not crossing police tape – is obstructing or compromising an investigation in any way. Let’s hope the CPD reviews this case, along with their policies. 

About these ads

29 Responses to “No Shooting Shootings, Says Chicago Police”


  1. 1 Oronare October 23, 2008 at 9:39 pm

    It IS illegal to delete memory cards. Period.

    It is the property of the Photographer and they can not be tampered with in any way unless they have a warrant to look at them.

    He should lodge a formal complaint and take them to court. More and more photographers and videographers are seeing themselves harassed by Police and “Security” and these people need to learn the laws they are trying to enforce.

  2. 2 Bretzelman October 23, 2008 at 10:14 pm

    Did you tried recovering the pictures using a tool like RescuePro (it’s bunled with the sandisk extreme III and IV cards).

    I’ve had such a similar problem with the belgian police last summer (without the shooting scene, but they arrested my very brutally just ’cause I took pictures of them arresting people). They erased some pictures on the card but I recovered them easily with rescue pro.

    It seems that it works “not so bad” even if they format the card.

  3. 3 Hughes Léglise-Bataille October 23, 2008 at 11:07 pm

    I’m not familiar with US laws but here in France, such a police behavior would be totally unacceptable. If the photographer was in a public space, outside of the police lines, there’s absolutely no ground for preventing him to take pictures, even for a normal citizen (i.e. not a journalist). As for erasing a memory card or even seizing the camera, both would be completely unlawful. That’s really a shame. However, I did have the same issue while shooting arrests in France. Some police officers are either not properly trained, or they just like to abuse their authority (and esp. don’t like to be resisted !). It would be good if you could find back the people present at the scene as testimonies. Plus your own pictures if you can manage to restore them !

  4. 4 mr walker October 24, 2008 at 12:14 am

    google: file recovery software.

    the deleted photos probably contain evidence to contradict the charges against him.

  5. 5 i know what you are up against October 24, 2008 at 3:33 am

    This is the Chicago police we are talking about and the police lines are drawn where the old color lines used to fall. I’m afraid if the photographer would like to keep shooting police and crime scenes in Chicago he will absorb this hit and acknowledge that raising the issue too strongly could do more to block future access. Such is life when we have left the law to thugs.

  6. 6 James Madison October 24, 2008 at 5:17 am

    This isn’t legal advice, but . . . I smell a big, fat, righteous 42 U.S.C. § 1983 suit. You should talk to an attorney. If no one else, the ACLU might be interested in this.

  7. 7 the malaga 1 October 24, 2008 at 3:10 pm

    im not surprised. the orwelian police state has already happened.. the trouble is that the people of the usa and uk etc havent woken up to the fact. when everyone opens their eyes you will realise that we have no real freedom of speach.. very sad but this isnt the first or last time this will happen

  8. 8 WTF October 24, 2008 at 10:53 pm

    sounds like some bitch had a power trip

  9. 9 WOW October 24, 2008 at 11:46 pm

    Can’t wait for Chicago politics to go national!

  10. 10 paperboy October 26, 2008 at 10:11 pm

    Disgusting police thugs who shouldn’t even be allowed to fill their stomachs on the taxpayer’s dime. Anyone who deletes photos or audio recordings or confiscates reporter notebooks must be prosecuted.

    Everyone says only a small percentage of cops are bad, but where are the voices of the good cops now? Who is protecting the right of the people to know what is happening in their own cities?

    We have to rid ourselves of cops so full of themselves that they victimize the people the are sworn to serve. If they aren’t sophisticated enough to understand the oath, they should at least appreciate the pay check.

    We must have prosecutions, civil suits. We must protect the right of Americans to know and not have government officials cut off information they may need.

    This if not about reporters or newspapers or cops. This is about Americans and their right to know. What police do in one place, they can do elsewhere.

  11. 11 BayTaperDotCom November 7, 2008 at 9:00 pm

    What I find truely ironic is that it was actually THE COPS that have obstructed your justice. They in fact have destroyed evidence related to YOUR CHARGES. That alone should get your case dropped, and should also result in disciplinary action against the officer(s) who did the deleting. That’s IN ADDITION to the fact that they violated the law in arresting you and deleting the images in the first place. You see the difference? That’s evidence that’s relates to where you were standing and what you were doing, and that evidence must be preserved in and of itself.

  12. 12 vaguninfo.com November 24, 2008 at 1:04 pm

    The photographer needs to sue the city for a DMCA complaint as he is the rightful copyright owner of those images.

  13. 13 rescue files January 17, 2014 at 3:44 pm

    My coder is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP.

    I have always disliked the idea because of the costs.
    But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on numerous websites for about a year and am concerned about switching
    to another platform. I have heard good things about blogengine.net.

    Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress posts into
    it? Any kind of help would be really appreciated!

  14. 14 twitter March 14, 2014 at 4:08 pm

    I constantly spent my half an hour to read this weblog’s posts daily along
    with a mug of coffee.

  15. 15 nachtwäsche June 12, 2014 at 7:37 pm

    W naszym wieku organy, codziennie rzeczy skręcenie na Wybierz rzeczy lub codziennie działania, takie jak wprowadzenie artykuły gospodarstwa domowego w samochodzie może stać się
    bolesne Opłaty. Ból od choroby stawów i kilka ujemna Skutki starzenie na pewno może
    zrobić życia ciężko. Kiedy jesteś skupienie się
    na reżim diety, suplementy diety Fitness i ćwiczenia złagodzić Problem
    nie bój zapytać o pomocy choć sklep zakupy lub Przedsiębiorstwo inne codziennie porządki.
    Jesteś prawo do to! nachtwäsche Nigdy nie nigdy zastosowanie krem gdy jesteś w wielkim pośpiechu, bo to zawsze przyczyny awaria!
    To naprawdę jest 1 elegancja pozycja naprawdę trzeba zainwestować trochę czasu z bo znaleźć się polowanie dziwaczne, więc czyste krem
    łokcie ponad stawy kolanowe i . ft i mycia ręce dokładnie do
    chronić się przed smug. Wykorzystaj swoje krem dużym wyprzedzeniem z odpoczynku zapobiegać Cały Pech kariera i z wyprzedzeniem któregokolwiek specjalne okazje,
    w przypadku,! nachtwäsche Jak podano najpierw na to artykule, najprawdopodobniej posiadać czas
    na piękna Program wraz z stresującym rutynowej. O jakiś
    czas kiedy Twój posiłek rano musi być utworzona, młodzież powinien dostać gotowy
    dla szkoła i powinieneś dostać działać ? O tak i nie zapomnieć o po prostu chodzić i daje
    Twój zwierzak. To może być męczące! Apply prosta urody porady z tego Artykuł
    i będziesz wygląd dużo więcej odnowione od razu.

    nachtwäsche Istnieją 19 spożywcze które są uważany powinien elementy w
    twoje lodówka i kuchnia spiżarnia, i tak będzie, Funkcja niesamowite rzeczy dla zdrowia i witalność
    gdy Era. Napisz to dolna i Publikuj w domu na utrzymanie
    sobie przypomniał zostać zaopatrzony: owoce morza,
    nabiał, zielony szpinak, orzechy, organiczna
    oliwa z oliwek niezbędny, brokuły, owsiane,
    mączka z nasion lnu, awokado, granat soki owocowe pomidory, tofu, niskotłuszczowy jogurt,
    kolorze czerwonym cebule, czosnek herb, fasola i soczewica!

    To może wydawać jak wiele jednak jest to najmniej można zrobić, na siebie i
    wyników możesz generowanie z twojego posiłek organizowanie
    inicjatywy! nachtwäsche Koniecznie się słońce, ale nie nadmiernie.
    Gdy Era, to istotne do zidentyfikować Harmonia w odniesieniu do spożywanie bezpośrednie światło słoneczne.
    To istotne, a światło słoneczne jest wspaniałym sposobem uzyskać witaminy Suplement D do program, ale
    słońcu może mieć Wyniki na starzeje skóra i rak skóry.
    Uchwyt Twój czas i wysiłek w słońcu i gdy jesteś w to
    na zewnątrz, nosić wielkie balsam do opalania.
    nachtwäsche To naprawdę jest w żaden sposób późno zatrzymać palenie
    papierosów dla jako sposób powolne starzenie. Używanie tytoniu
    nie po prostu podnosi niebezpieczeństwo o rak płuc i rozedma płuc, jest związana liczne rodzaje raka odmian raka, choroby sercowo-choroby serca, wraz z obniżona potencjał do czynienia
    z problemy zdrowotne. Naturalnie, Dodatkowo ma okropne wpływ
    na skóra. Przez Stop smoking, starzenie może być a może i
    będziesz przedłużyć życie codzienne długość.

    nachtwäsche Bynajmniej może zastosowanie krem gdy jesteś w pośpiechu
    gdyż będą przyczyny awaria! To naprawdę jest 1 splendor obiekt trzeba
    zainwestować trochę czasu z bo znaleźć się szuka
    dziwaczne, więc elegancki krem łokcie ponad kolana i stóp i mycia ręce dokładnie zapobiec smug.
    korzystać z krem dużym wyprzedzeniem z odpoczynku zatrzymać kompletne Pech
    Zadanie i z wyprzedzeniem któregokolwiek wielki dzień, w razie!

    nachtwäsche Bo stało się starzeje należy
    tylko relaks i spokojnie. Aby zdrowie i dobre samopoczucie,
    należy nadal jak produktywne jak można. Pewność, można w stanie po
    prostu pójść i zawody w maraton, jednak, ty nadal integracja Proces do ciebie codzienne czynności.
    To jest zalecane które include przynajmniej 30 minut z ćwiczenia codziennie.
    Może mogli wziąć – chwilę spacery chodzić dwa razy dziennie.
    Motocykle z dala, że starym rower i iść na dysku całej
    Społeczność. nachtwäsche Toksyny są szkodliwe po towarów tworzy
    w ciała nawróceni wyżywienie i świeże powietrze do energia.
    Głównie dlatego, że kontrolą wszystkie te Toksyny, przeciwutleniacze ziołowe może pomóc
    jesteś uchwyt wyniki z starzeje. Źródła przeciwutleniacze,
    witaminy są owoce, warzywa, i pełnoziarniste. Borówki, jeżyny, brokuły, szpinak|i zielony szpinak Kapusta są szczególnie atrakcyjne,
    jak pożądane więcej ciemne produkty żywnościowe mają zazwyczaj lepiej objętość przeciwutleniacze.
    nachtwäsche Chcesz żywo długie życie codzienne i rozkoszować
    proces starzenia? Żyć długo, nadal korzystne.
    raporty wystawiał, że ludzie, którzy optymistyczne postawa także mają zazwyczaj dłuższych i zdrowsze życia.
    Spróbuj znaleźć na humor życia. Zabawa może niższe, że wysokie ciśnienie krwi i pomocy pusty
    lęk prawo ze swojego całe ciało. Liczne badania pokazują, przycisk dobre Moc z śmiechu
    i jak to zrobić czujesz znacznie lepiej.

  16. 16 badeanzüge damen 2013 June 23, 2014 at 4:23 pm

    Przedstawiamy zielona herbata liściasta do pliku codziennie Program może naprawdę poprawić swoje contra – – starzeje Program!
    Zielona herbata liściasta może pomóc zbudować
    Opozycja na dużo choroby takie jak wiele form raka i może jesteś przeciwko, demencji i innych nerwowe dolegliwości
    z starzeje. Także mieć świadomość, Ekstrakt liści zielonej herbaty może pomóc systemu w jego zdolność do spalić tłuszcz,
    co czyni go trwający dodatek do Twój sklep spożywczy lista jest bardzo świetny pomysł!
    Wolne rodniki są destrukcyjne po produkty utworzona
    dla całe ciało zamienia wyżywienie i świeże powietrze do witalność.

    Ponieważ kontrolą wszystkie te wolne rodniki, przeciwutleniacze
    może pomóc jesteś zająć wpływ z starzenie. Zasoby dla przeciwutleniacze
    są świeże owoce, warzywa świeże, i produkty pełnego ziarna.
    Borówki, jeżyny, brokuły, szpinak|i są zwłaszcza ciemniejsze żywność
    zazwyczaj zwiększył objętość przeciwutleniacze.

  17. 17 HéBergement De Serveur Minecraft Gratuit August 30, 2014 at 11:54 am

    For many gamers, guild clan website hosting can mean the difference between a guilds life or death,
    literally. You will see absolutely no need for you
    to definitely talk about the host along with other web site unlike on a distributed machine.
    You may want to increase the amount of RAM allocated to your
    server, as Craftbukkit will require more memory, especially with plugins.

  18. 18 alexber.blog.com September 2, 2014 at 11:37 am

    Hi all, here every one is sharing such knowledge, so it’s pleasant to
    read this website, and I used to pay a visit this weblog everyday.

  19. 19 best broadway musicals September 4, 2014 at 1:20 am

    Get a copy of a computer software instrument; you can make just about any kind of sound by
    utilizing your personal computer or Mac pc. At numerous places of work where folks just just work at work desk, crucial vocals is a respite from tension for these people.
    New Technologies has been around since the 1960s-70s that paved just how
    for several new types.

  20. 20 online casino September 17, 2014 at 6:43 am

    Good post! We will be linking to this particularly great content on our site.

    Keep up the great writing.

  21. 21 stemologica Review September 20, 2014 at 3:39 pm

    Hi, I would like to subscribe for this web site to get
    most up-to-date updates, thus where can i do it please assist.

  22. 22 sex October 4, 2014 at 12:09 am

    When I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I
    get several emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that
    service? Appreciate it!

  23. 23 addie Up October 4, 2014 at 11:21 pm

    Please let me know if you’re looking for
    a article writer for your blog. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset.

    If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some articles for your
    blog in exchange for a link back to mine.
    Please send me an e-mail if interested. Thanks!


  1. 1 Update: Arrested Photog’s Photos Recovered « Trackback on October 24, 2008 at 5:05 pm
  2. 2 dvafoto - M. Scott Brauer and Matt Lutton › United States ranked 36 in world for press freedom Trackback on October 25, 2008 at 1:58 am
  3. 3 Chicago Photographer Arrested Again - CPD on the Warpath « Trackback on November 18, 2008 at 7:03 pm
  4. 4 Court Clears Chicago Photojournalist « Trackback on February 10, 2009 at 3:09 am
  5. 5 The Criminalization of Photographers | Visual Arts Junction Trackback on April 1, 2009 at 11:36 am
  6. 6 he said Trackback on October 7, 2014 at 2:54 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s





Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 251 other followers

%d bloggers like this: